The Powers of War and Peace
The Constitution and Foreign Affairs after 9/11
378 pages
|
6 x 9
|
© 2005
Since the September 11 attacks on the United States, the Bush administration has come under fire for its methods of combating terrorism. Waging war against al Qaeda has proven to be a legal quagmire, with critics claiming that the administration's response in Afghanistan and Iraq is unconstitutional. The war on terror—and, in a larger sense, the administration's decision to withdraw from the ABM Treaty and the Kyoto accords—has many wondering whether the constitutional framework for making foreign affairs decisions has been discarded by the present administration.
John Yoo, formerly a lawyer in the Department of Justice, here makes the case for a completely new approach to understanding what the Constitution says about foreign affairs, particularly the powers of war and peace. Looking to American history, Yoo points out that from Truman and Korea to Clinton's intervention in Kosovo, American presidents have had to act decisively on the world stage without a declaration of war. They are able to do so, Yoo argues, because the Constitution grants the president, Congress, and the courts very different powers, requiring them to negotiate the country's foreign policy. Yoo roots his controversial analysis in a brilliant reconstruction of the original understanding of the foreign affairs power and supplements it with arguments based on constitutional text, structure, and history.
Accessibly blending historical arguments with current policy debates, The Powers of War and Peace will no doubt be hotly debated. And while the questions it addresses are as old and fundamental as the Constitution itself, America's response to the September 11 attacks has renewed them with even greater force and urgency.
John Yoo, formerly a lawyer in the Department of Justice, here makes the case for a completely new approach to understanding what the Constitution says about foreign affairs, particularly the powers of war and peace. Looking to American history, Yoo points out that from Truman and Korea to Clinton's intervention in Kosovo, American presidents have had to act decisively on the world stage without a declaration of war. They are able to do so, Yoo argues, because the Constitution grants the president, Congress, and the courts very different powers, requiring them to negotiate the country's foreign policy. Yoo roots his controversial analysis in a brilliant reconstruction of the original understanding of the foreign affairs power and supplements it with arguments based on constitutional text, structure, and history.
Accessibly blending historical arguments with current policy debates, The Powers of War and Peace will no doubt be hotly debated. And while the questions it addresses are as old and fundamental as the Constitution itself, America's response to the September 11 attacks has renewed them with even greater force and urgency.
“Can the president of the United States do whatever he likes in wartime without oversight from Congress or the courts? This year, the issue came to a head as the Bush administration struggled to maintain its aggressive approach to the detention and interrogation of suspected enemy combatants in the war on terrorism. But this was also the year that the administration’s claims about presidential supremacy received their most sustained intellectual defense [in] The Powers of War and Peace.”—Jeffrey Rosen, New York Times
“Yoo’s theory promotes frank discussion of the national interest and makes it harder for politicians to parade policy conflicts as constitutional crises. Most important, Yoo’s approach offers a way to renew our political system’s democratic vigor.”—David B. Rivkin Jr. and Carlos Ramos-Mrosovsky, National Review
“Yoo’s theory promotes frank discussion of the national interest and makes it harder for politicians to parade policy conflicts as constitutional crises. Most important, Yoo’s approach offers a way to renew our political system’s democratic vigor.”—David B. Rivkin Jr. and Carlos Ramos-Mrosovsky, National Review
“In The Powers of War and Peace John Yoo has produced a brilliant and pathbreaking analysis of the constitutional roles of the president, Congress, and the courts in deciding to initiate and wage wars and in managing our foreign relations. Beginning with the history that informed the framers of the Constitution, Professor Yoo carries his argument forward to the world the United States confronts in the aftermath of 9/11, including our wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. This is the most original and compelling work on this crucial topic that I know of.”--Judge Robert H. Bork, Fellow, Hudson Institute
“The Powers of War and Peace is one of the most comprehensive, thoughtful, and provocative works written about the relationship between foreign affairs and constitutional law. It forces us to think deeply about the challenges faced by our nation in a world of rogue nations and terrorism, increasing globalization and trade, and more powerful international institutions, and their relationship with fundamental questions concerning the balance of powers among the president, Congress, and the courts. The Powers of War and Peace should be read by all of those interested in foreign affairs, national security, and constitutional law.”--The Honorable Laurence H. Silberman, U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit and former co-chair of the President’s Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction
"A convincing and judicious case for the need in a post-September 11 era to re-evaluate what the Constitution says about foreign affairs. Mr. Yoo's book covers a broad range of foreign policy areas like international law, treaties and multilateralism and addresses each with clarity and scholarly care. But at its heart, The Powers of War and Peace is a scathing criticism of those whom he argues have neglected their constitutional responsibility. . . . A valuable contribution to the tradition of works about the Constitution and foreign affairs. Like The Prince, it uses insider knowledge to boldly state political truths that others dare not utter."--Nicholas J. Xenakis, The Washington Times
"Can the president of the United States do whatever he likes in wartime without oversight from Congress or the courts? This year, the issue came to a head as the Bush administration struggled to maintain its aggressive approach to the detention and interrogation of suspected enemy combatants in the war on terrorism. But this was also the year that the administration's claims about presidential supremacy received their most sustained intellectual defense [in] The Powers of War and Peace."--Jeffrey Rosen, The New York Times
"There is a refreshing elegance to Yoo's theory. Forgoing hair-splitting doctrinal debates about congressional and executive claims to primacy in foreign affairs, Yoo tells the two branches to duke it out politically, deploying their allocated powers to reach a political equilibrium. By shifting the debate from the legal to the political arena, Yoo's theory promotes frank discussion of the national interest and makes it harder for politicians to parade policy conflicts as constitutional crises. Most important, Yoo's approach offers a way to renew our political system's democratic vigor. . . . An impressive scholarly achievement, The Powers of War and Peace should be read by anyone with an interest in constitutional law and foreign policy."--David B. Rivkin Jr. & Carlos Ramos-Mrosovsky, National Review
“The book argues that the Constitution gives the president a much larger role in foreign affairs and military operations than the other two branches of the federal government, that the president does not need a congressional declaration of war before placing troops on the ground and that treaties ratified the Senate have no legal impact unless Congress explicitly passes laws saying that they do.”
"This is an outstanding volume, one that will make an enduring contribution to the literature on the the Constitution and foreign relations. . . . I came away from the book persuaded that many, but not all, of Yoo's constitutional submissions are correct. One should not let the status of this author--as a controversial public intellectual and public servant--stand in the way of appreciating his important scholarship."
"It is rare that one scholar fundamentally recasts the debate on a constitutional issue of pressing public importance. In The Powers of War and Peace, John Yoo has done exactly that."
"[Yoo] is a formidable legal scholar, whose new book provides reason to believe that the administration's broad understanding of the constitutional allocation of war powers is supported by constitutional text, history and structure. . . . By clarifying the theory of government on which the current administration relies in waging war and pursuing peace, [Yoo] has rendered a genuine service to all, on both sides of the aisle, who wish to uphold the Constitution and defend the nation."
Contents
Preface
1. Introduction
2. The Eighteenth-Century Anglo-American Constitution and Foreign Affairs
3. Foreign Affairs and the Prelude to the Constitution
4. Writing and Ratifying a Foreign Affairs Constitution
5. War Powers for a New World
6. International Politics as Law? Interpreting and Ending Treaties
7. Treaties and the Legislative Power
8. Laws as Treaties? Statutes as International Agreements
9. The Constitution and the Multilateral Future
Notes
Index
1. Introduction
2. The Eighteenth-Century Anglo-American Constitution and Foreign Affairs
3. Foreign Affairs and the Prelude to the Constitution
4. Writing and Ratifying a Foreign Affairs Constitution
5. War Powers for a New World
6. International Politics as Law? Interpreting and Ending Treaties
7. Treaties and the Legislative Power
8. Laws as Treaties? Statutes as International Agreements
9. The Constitution and the Multilateral Future
Notes
Index
For more information, or to order this book, please visit http://www.press.uchicago.edu
Google preview here
Law and Legal Studies: Legal History | The Constitution and the Courts
Political Science: Diplomacy, Foreign Policy, and International Relations
You may purchase this title at these fine bookstores. Outside the USA, see our international sales information.
