Friends of the Unrighteous Mammon
Northern Christians and Market Capitalism, 1815-1860
Drawing on diverse primary sources, Davenport identifies three distinct Christian responses to market capitalism: assurance from clerical economists who believed in the righteousness of economic development; opposition from contrarians who resisted the changes around them; and adaptation by the pastoral moralists who modified their faith to meet the ethical challenges of the changing economy. Delving into the minds of antebellum Christians as they considered themselves, their God, and their developing American economy, Friends of the Unrighteous Mammon is an ambitious intellectual history of an important development in American religious and economic life.
“An important contribution to a much-neglected but very important subject. No other author has set out to do what Davenport accomplishes, which is a systematic study of how key representatives of America’s rising tide of religion attempted a theoretical understanding of, and practical response to, America’s rising tide of commerce.”
“Stewart Davenport conscientiously and insightfully re-creates the world of the nineteenth-century political economists, who taught that the principles of international trade manifested, like the laws of biology and physics, the intelligent design of a Divine Creator.”
“Friends of the Unrighteous Mammon is an illuminating and original examination of religious thought about political economy in nineteenth-century America, and thereby of deep and enduring conflicts within market societies.”
“Scholars have endlessly written about antebellum Protestant thinking about slavery. Now, finally, Friends of the Unrighteous Mammon turns a spotlight on a new, crucial question: how did antebellum Protestants parse capitalism? For anyone who seeks to understand the political economy of the antebellum era—or, indeed, the complex entanglement of Christianity and capitalism today—this book is critical. I, for one, am very grateful to Stewart Davenport for having written it.”
Introduction: Self and Society in an American Modernity
I “ASSURED”—THE CLERICAL ECONOMISTS
1 Originally Sinful: “Das Adam Smith Problem” and the “Dismal Science”
2 People and Project
3 Motivations
4 Moral Problems, Scientific Solutions
5 Utilitarian Conclusions—Moral Man, Moral Economy
II UNRESOLVED QUESTIONS
6 The Inconsistently Virtuous Economy 7 The Problem of the Poor
III “OPPOSED”—THE CONTRARIANS
8 Stephen Colwell
9 Orestes Brownson Before 1840
10 Orestes Brownson After 1840
11 Some Comparisons and Preliminary Conclusions
IV “ADAPTED"—THE PASTORAL MORALISTS
12 Paradox, People, and Project
13 Boundaries, Balance, and Faculty Psychology
14 Of Competition and Liberalism, Luxury and Speculation
15 Divine Retribution and “Das Adam Smith Problem” Revisited
Conclusion: Friends of the Unrighteous Mammon
Notes
Bibliography
Index
History: American History
Religion: American Religions | Religion and Society
You may purchase this title at these fine bookstores. Outside the USA, see our international sales information.





